FluffyUnicorn
FluffyUnicorn

Job offer rescinded after salary negotiation

I recently encountered a situation while job hunting in the engineering field. I applied for a role in a company where I had limited experience with their specific projects. When asked about my salary expectations, I mentioned ₹XX lakh, which seemed to surprise them.

They offered ₹10 lakh less than my expectation. I countered by suggesting ₹XX-5 lakh, with a provision to increase to ₹XX after a six-month probation, contingent on performance. They rescinded the offer without any explanation.

I'm not upset about it, as it might have been a mismatch. However, the lack of communication was puzzling. The offer was made on Thursday at 4:00 PM, with a deadline of 12 noon Tuesday after a long weekend.

For context, I was applying for an intermediate project engineer position. I have 5 years of experience, mainly in wood structures, while this role involved steel structures. The initial offer was ₹8.5 lakh.

Did I handle the negotiation poorly, or did I avoid a potential issue? Insights from others who've faced similar situations would be appreciated.

11mo ago
Jobs
One interview, 1000+ job opportunities
Take a 10-min AI interview to qualify for numerous real jobs auto-matched to your profile 🔑
+322 new users this month
ZestyQuokka
ZestyQuokka
Hinge11mo

I discuss budget in screening round itself, saves both of us time and effort

DerpyPotato
DerpyPotato
Intuit11mo

The lack of communication is a huge issue here. If they can't be transparent during hiring, how can you trust them with your career?

GigglyPickle
GigglyPickle

Were you involved in the recent layoffs by any chance?

ZestyDumpling
ZestyDumpling

You might have overestimated your leverage. Companies want to see relevant experience, not just years on paper.

DancingDonut
DancingDonut
DotPe11mo

Expecting them to agree to a probationary increase without showing results first? That's not how it works.

Discover more
Curated from across
Business Roles
by ZestyMuffinCommunication

Negotiating a higher salary

I'm been on the lookout for a new job and the first question recruiters ask is if I have an offer in hand and what's my expected CTC.

The next time, i get asked from a recruiter if I have an offer in hand, I want to say yes. Is there a...

Product Managers
by SleepyTacoProduct Management

Weird recruiter experiences

I'll go first. I got a call for an APM role from one of the companies which did sound pretty sketchy and the recruiter was started bullying me into answering questions, when I asked to know more about the role. The recruiter was extremel...

Top comments
user

Asked for my expected CTC. I answered and they weren't happy with it. Said they could only give at 40% increment of c...

user

One YC backed startup run by 24-25 year old folks asked me to join them as an ML engineer, took my interview, rolled ...

user

Years ago, before WhiteHat was acquired, I got a call from their HR for a PM role. They asked my current CTC. I ...

Layoffs
by GoofyPenguinSoftware Engineer

Did I do the right thing turning down a 40% hike offer

So I recently gave an interview to a company, cracked it and got offered 50% hike but I was very hesitant joining there because they said they'll demote my role to a Jr Engineer, because they said my code wasn't as good as they wanted. ...

Company Reviews
by FluffyWalrusCapgemini

Infosys Interview Process

I have had 2 rounds of interviews, technical and managerial, they have scheduled one more round with senior management but they have not showed up for the interview. Later I got a call from HR and they have scheduled HR interview. And, H...