BouncyCupcake
BouncyCupcake

Biggest defence scam

UPA negotiated a far better deal which the BJP government turned into a joke for the country. Well done!

Post image
8mo ago
Talking product sense with Ridhi
9 min AI interview5 questions
Round 1 by Grapevine
GoofyDonut
GoofyDonut

To be fair, rupee has declined by a lot in the last 10y

ZestyPenguin
ZestyPenguin
Student8mo

Which still warrants the same criticism lmao

DerpyBagel
DerpyBagel
PWC8mo

Your interpretation is incorrect , I actually know people who originally negotiated the contract , the corruption that was attempted for 10 years and the price escalation that happens when you try to buy something in 2016 instead of 2006 because your force levels are struggling and you have to buy what's available at the price it is. There was no corruption by BJP here

DerpyBagel
DerpyBagel
PWC8mo

Also keep in mind that none of these people writing books actually have a transparent visibility to manufacturing mix configuration , service and support package ( missiles , radars , carrier compatibility , interoperability between forces ) there were attempts made by Congress to pull another vikrant (old one) but at the cost of multiple honest defence officers careers the corruption was avoided. The delay however was a consequence of not being corruptible.

ZestySushi
ZestySushi

TL;DR NDA's deal is far better . I see an XUV700 can be bought for ₹ 14 lakhs, but I can also pay upto ₹ 26 lakhs for it. Does it make sense for anyone to go for top variant when base one can be had for close to half the price? . The 42k cr (₹ 333 cr / fighter) price quoted above is of the initial 'soft' agreement arrived in Jan 2012. That price only includes a acquisition cost, without any costs of parts and maintenance for several years to come. Moreoever it didn't include the costs of improvements in weapons package, better electro-optic systems, superior avionics and many IAF-specific customizations that increase the potency of these fighters significantly, all of which were included in NDA's deal. . But the biggest blunder of UPA was complete misunderstanding of contract in which Dassault Aviation was essentially exempted of any accountability of the quality of the 110 aircrafts to be manufactured by HAL in India. This glaring omission meant that IAF was uncertain if at any given point of time we would even have more 50 aircrafts available in combat-ready condition (recall that serviceability and uptime was a major factor why IAF narrowed down on Rafale in the first place). When HAL's revised estimates of man-hours needed to produce and maintain the fighters was factored in, the deal had already ballooned up to ₹ 1.86 lakh crores (₹ 1444 cr / fighter) by Jan 2014 (4.4x of the 42k cr price quoted in above article). . Needless to say, inflation plays a big part too and therefore the numbers aren't closely comparable. Yet the final price of NDA's deal at 60k cr (₹ 1666 / fighter) is only 15% above the advanced stage price UPA's deal, notwithstanding the inflation & overall equipment improvement. . So indeed once you understand the overall higher oomph offered by the AX7 variant of XUV700 (and assume it comes with free service + parts for first 5 years), you begin realizing why it costs about double the 5Str baseline model. Of course the this stupid analogy doesn't capture the criticality of military equipment, operations and strategy which considers nation's security, and not expenditure, of paramount interest. . In the end all I can say is the author of above article either failed to research enough on the topic or decided to purposefully obscure facts & figures to unknown ulterior motives. . Jai Hind.

PeppyJellybean
PeppyJellybean

What is the source of these numbers?

BouncyCupcake
BouncyCupcake
image
SquishyHamster
SquishyHamster

I remember there was some discussion around the price tag that the Congress guys ommited calculations , plane per price is also taking into account many factors other than just the plane. Did you check that angle Op?

BouncyCupcake
BouncyCupcake

Read

image
SquishyHamster
SquishyHamster

Can't read a book bro

SillyMochi
SillyMochi

Inflation babu bhaiya

DerpyPretzel
DerpyPretzel

Inflation plus configuration is different. Earlier govt bought inferior, which probably was good enough for that time not now

SwirlyTaco
SwirlyTaco

Do you know anything about the word "inflation"?

FuzzyJellybean
FuzzyJellybean

Inflation

JumpyCupcake
JumpyCupcake

Do a better research man . You need better understanding to understand these defence acquisitions and the geopolitical standings of the countries and the government relations plus the other forces acting behind.

Discover more
Curated from across
News Discussion
by JumpyNoodleProduct Manager

Who is more corrupt- Congress or BJP? Why?

Can people compare scams like Electoral Bonds vs 2g scam?

Top comments
user

Current scams came to light only after SC’s intervention. Currently all our media houses are busy bootlicking and not...

user

Serious question as I want to understand this - how is Electoral Bond a scam? Today we know who funded which pa...

News Discussion
by WigglyDonutGrowth Manager

Election Results 2024: BJP winning?

Looks like things aren’t as rosy as they would have seemed for BJP Most NDA projections seem to be ending at 320 as upper cap

What are you guys thinking? What does this mean for India? What does it mean for us?

Post image
Top comments
user

Good. People have shown that building a temple in one corner of the country is not enough. A strong opposition is nee...

user

The big headline acc to me: Media called I.N.D.I.A alliance practically a pool of jokers. Nobody expected them to do ...

user

Good to see that the exit polls were wrong, and that democracy and the opposition are still alive and kicking. ...