FluffyNugget
FluffyNugget
31mo

When part prepaying home loan…

Is it better to

Reduce EMI (please comment reason)
Reduce tenure (please comment reason)
🍿
512 votesexpired
31mo ago
ZoomyMuffin
ZoomyMuffin

As someone in finance, if your interest rate is lower, then Do not prepay and if you do, lower your EMI.

If you are well financially, loan shouldn't be a mental liability, it is a flexibility. Always keep the liquidity high and available,

FluffyNugget
FluffyNugget
31mo

What would be a low interest rate? It’s at 8.6 currently.

ZoomyMuffin
ZoomyMuffin

To support with numbers, actual lost of loan pre-tax: Rate differential: 8.5% - 6.5%=2% On 1Cr principal outstanding: 17k monthly

17k is your monthly cost to access 1Cr money. That's manageable.

GoofyPickle
GoofyPickle

If you have enough money to pay your EMI,why pay interest for a longer period on an amount. EMI reduction looks like a scam to me if you are prepaying a home loan.

FluffyNugget
FluffyNugget
31mo

It makes sense if u would like to keep the loan on which has the least interest rate and effective interest rate is much lower if u use it in old regime of tax.

SqueakyQuokka
SqueakyQuokka

Even if tax rate is lower, you may reduce your tax liability, but you would be paying an interest, which is a higher liability.

CosmicRaccoon
CosmicRaccoon

Better to reduce tenure. Once you reduce tenure, your total interest paid on the loan will decrease. Whereas, if you reduce EMI, your interest paid would still be more than compared to the previous point. Since, tenure would be same.

FluffyNugget
FluffyNugget
31mo

Hmm is the difference significant? Bcoz don’t the banks recover most of the interest in like first 5 years.

SqueakyQuokka
SqueakyQuokka

You only pay the interest that is applicable for those years and not for the entire duration of the loan.

FloatingWaffle
FloatingWaffle
31mo

Reducing tenure, reduces the total amount that you will pay to bank, since tenure is less you will pay interest for less time, thus less money.

EMI reduction doesn't makes sense to me.

FluffyNugget
FluffyNugget
31mo

Yes I understand and this looks like the popular option. But there could be 2 reasons to reduce EMI:

  • You can invest the difference
  • It’s possible that u get a pay cut in future or have to be off work for longer term (so will help maintain ur budget)
ZoomyMuffin
ZoomyMuffin

You wouldn't want to do that.

DO NOT look at total interest outgo. That number is misleading. Interest is a cost, so look at monthly outgo.

Loan is a service, interest is the cost you pay for that. Prepaying home loans of 8-9% interest rate is like selling your car to avoid the monthly parking cost!!!

Prepaying is also irreversible decision. Please consult an adviser before you proceed.

WigglyNoodle
WigglyNoodle
31mo

As someone who values peace of mind, just prepay as much as you can and don't reduce EMI --> get rid of the damn loan..when it comes to loans don't do financial math, just finish it.

FluffyNugget
FluffyNugget
31mo

I agree. Just looking for takes.

ZippyMarshmallow
ZippyMarshmallow
31mo

I completely agree with you. Why is everyone thinking the leverage pov for individuals. That POV should be applicable for companies only. As individuals we cannot manage lot of things like a org/entity.

GoofyDonut
GoofyDonut

Get data from your org and tell us too :p

FluffyNugget
FluffyNugget
31mo

Data would be useless to us peasants. What High Net-worth Individuals do, wouldn’t necessarily benefit us 🥲

SqueakyMuffin
SqueakyMuffin
31mo

This is a fun thread.
OP says you should reduce EMI so that you can invest the difference for higher returns, and get more tax benefit.

This makes absolutely no sense.

  • If you are making a higher post-tax return than your home loan elsewhere, why would you prepay principal in the first place? Just invest it all?

  • You have cash in hand. You want to pay more interest over the loan cycle to the bank so that you can get a 30% rebate from the taxman.
    Go ahead and give up the rest 70% from your pockets.

No wonder banks make like 15k+ cr profit a quarter nowadays

FluffyNugget
FluffyNugget
31mo

That’s one of the reasons I have come across for reducing EMI and was keen on understanding its validity. The other thing, people do try to keep home loan ongoing even if they can pay it off bcoz interest is low. So ya they’re investing or doing smthng else with that capital and not prepaying.

ZoomyMuffin
ZoomyMuffin

Looking at the replies, as someone who works in lending, I would urge people to consider to not prepay.

DO NOT look at total interest outgo. That number is misleading. Interest is a cost, so look at monthly outgo.

Loan is a service, interest is the cost you pay for that. Prepaying home loans of 8-9% interest rate is like selling your car to avoid the monthly parking cost!!!

Prepaying is also irreversible decision. Please consult an adviser before you proceed.

QuirkyJellybean
QuirkyJellybean

Emi never get reduce in pre payment only tenure reduces

Discover more
Curated from across