FloatingNugget
FloatingNugget

Raja beta syndrome

Heard an old lady calling her “average doing son” - Raja Beta And treating her “associate partner in a consulting firm” daughter- badly only because she is a girl and according to her she won’t support her mother in her old age

Why are Indian mothers obsessed with “Raja Beta” even when the beta is good for nothing?

18d ago
Talking product sense with Ridhi
9 min AI interview5 questions
Round 1 by Grapevine
TwirlyCupcake
TwirlyCupcake

Curious to know why you didn't mention the designation of the Raja Beta here. And what makes you think the son is a good for nothing? And since she is an old lady she is most likely wired in a way that she considers her son to be her biggest asset. And it is the son who will most likely take care of her, provide, and protect till she dies. Even if the daughter wishes to, she may or may not be allowed by her husband or in-laws. So, it's still a gamble.

Indian parents in general are selfish creatures. They bring a life into this world purely with the intention of having someone who will take care of them when they are old, or to carry forward the family wealth. Now if she demeans her son at every given opportunity the fragile male ego can probably even kick her out of the house someday or stop caring for her since she will become a burden because she anyway doesn't respect his efforts. Would she risk it? I doubt.

FloatingNugget
FloatingNugget

Even if we accept this reasoning, she has no right to demean her daughter.
Daughters can get traumatized for life witnessing such things in their homes

DancingCoconut
DancingCoconut

I have been seeing some good perspective on most of the post @Walt. Appreciate your thought process👏

CosmicLlama
CosmicLlama

Maybe the son sacrificed a better job to help the family. May be the daughter is a feminist who thinks her money is "her" money and other's money is family money. May be the mother has the best interest of her daughter in her mind. She doesnt want to insult the future son in law by asking him to become a ghar jamai. May be the mother knows the daughter building her own nest is the best thing for her.

We dont know.

"Average doing" is not a measurement. My best friend is from IIT madras, he today today works in Infy for a 24L salary. His life is nothing but a collection of bad luck. Shit happens.

BubblyNoodle
BubblyNoodle

So many things wrong with this comment.

  1. Feminist, as you've used in the statement is incorrect and completely uncalled for. Why categorise a female for thinking her money is her money as a feminist. That's not what it means. People think that way, not just females.
  2. If asking your son-in-law to support yourself is "insulting" , then I don't understand why get your daughter married in such a place? You aren't sending her to some far off land forever where she can't come out of. Marriage is supposed to be a partnership. Both should be willing to take care of both sides of the family , if and when needed. Otherwise we are propagating this cycle of 'Rajabeta' and 'no-good' daughter all over again. We must teach our kids that being a girl doesn't mean you can't care for your family after marriage. Gender doesn't specify what you can or cannot do for your family.
  3. I agree with the "Average doing" comment. Just like that "feminist" doesn't mean selfish. It means equality.
    Written with the best of thoughts. Not to mock or point, but to clarify.
CosmicLlama
CosmicLlama

Misandry has been normalised to such an extent that even a benefit of doubt is not given.

Nonsensical feminist post.. and even more nonsensical to argue on this.

SwirlyMuffin
SwirlyMuffin

Internalized misogyny 😪

WobblyRaccoon
WobblyRaccoon

It's her choice

BouncyWalrus
BouncyWalrus

Good question 😂😂, would like to put it in easiest way possible Men are not allowed to be weak. Hence they are dependable. Specifically for your question about mother daughter and son, it's just her own perspective developed based on her life experience, she went to other family leaving parents behind, new responsibilities whereas their brother must have helped their parents, in old age they want to live without drama so that's why they are expecting their son will be the only person to reach out. Yes they can reach out to daughter also but she might have seen some consequences so that why she wanted to avoid that aspect and let her daughter live in peace. Don't easily generalize everything, single house paint can change the happiness of a family there are many parameters to be considered when talking about these matters.

Discover more
Curated from across
Adulting
by WobblyJellybeanAssociate Manager

My Wife not willing to share family expenses

Although I am married for 7 years, and me and my wife earn almost equal...when it comes to managing expenses, the constant issue I face is she is not interested to share even 20-30% of common expenses. The fight arises out of this every ...

Top comment
user

Find new wife.