DancingKoala

AITA: Breaking up with my(26F) boyfriend(26M) after my parents found an arranged match for me?

I (26F) have been dating my college sweetheart (26M) for 4 years. We met during BTech in India where we both studied Computer Science. After graduation, I moved to the US for my Masters and landed a job at FAANG, while he continued working in India.

Here's where things get complicated. My parents recently started pressuring me about marriage. When I told them about my boyfriend, they were completely against it.

Their reasons:

I have a Masters, he doesn't
I'm making significantly more money than him ($160k vs ₹28LPA)
They're worried about potential in-law issues since traditionally in our culture, wives earning more than husbands often face constant criticism.
They've found a "perfect match", same caste, MS from Northeastern, working at AWS Seattle, family is "very progressive".

My boyfriend and I had plans. He was going to come for his MS and then try for his H1B on his STEM-OPT, or I'd eventually move back. But my parents' concerns aren't entirely baseless. I've seen my cousin face constant taunts from her in-laws because she earns more than her husband.

The new guy seems decent on paper. We had a few video calls, and he seems respectful of my career. His family is explicitly okay with me continuing to work.

Yesterday, I broke up with my boyfriend. He was devastated and said I was choosing money and status over love. He called me materialistic and said I was letting my parents control my life. I am in India right now on a Diwali break. He keeps calling me and asks me to meet with him. What should I do?

9mo ago

Jobs

One interview, 1000+ job opportunities

Take a 10-min AI interview to qualify for numerous real jobs auto-matched to your profile 🔑

+322 new users this month

SquishyMarshmallow

Infosys9mo

your boyfriend dodged a bullet (you). good for him

GigglyBagel

Walmart9mo

How exactly is it OP'S fault?

BouncyHamster

Capgemini9mo

OP is a selfish person. Just accept it. Mostly you will have a decent marriage until you won't. Your ex in India will move on. You will however always second guess your love life while your ex won't. You won't get closure while your ex will.

A decent thing to do will be to make it work. What is life but making those large strides to make difficult things happen. Feel sorry for these gold digging people.

JumpyPretzel

Stealth9mo

How pathetic!! Give someone dreams and then break it all to pieces because parents!! Don’t give anyone hopes if the decisions of your life are not in your own hands.

DancingKoala

Stealth9mo

I hardly doubt it. Especially considering how Indian men literally kick their wives out of home if their mom throws a temper tantrum.

FloatingBagel

Stealth9mo

Ya...looks like your dad is Indian too...what if he kicks out you too (along with your mom). But don't worry...you will get better with time. Time heals. And Karma comes into picture...sooner or later.

WigglyMochi

Oracle9mo

Thank the gods that he didn't marry you. And you are literally asking how to cheat and break up with someone?

GigglyBagel

Walmart9mo

Where is she asking how to cheat and break up with someone?

DancingKoala

Stealth9mo

Yeah when did I even say that?

WobblyRaccoon

Hexagon9mo

Bol do you will get better, and i am sure he will. Give him a proper closure and move on

DancingKoala

Stealth9mo

I have told it to him but it’s a 4 year relationship

FluffyCupcake

Accenture9mo

Do you really wanted to be with him in the first place ? If so, he is ready to move US to be with you. What else you expect from him.

WigglyPenguin

Stealth9mo

Karma is a bitch

DancingKoala

Stealth9mo

It sure is. And it’s coming for you too

WigglyPenguin

Stealth9mo

and I'm about to get a lot of good karma 😌

SleepyKoala

Oracle9mo

I think parents are just an excuse and reason you wanted to justify breaking up with him for someone who can match your "status". If this post is real and if you are not just a troll that means you are just seeking validation from comments. Maybe you loved him and all during college, but now what you are feeling is not love its guilt. Guilt of hurting someone for your whinny selfish reasons. Also another thing according to Purchasing power parity is almost same, you can make ur parents understand that he is actually earning almost the same as you without masters degree so they shouldn't worry about the non existent salary difference.

DancingKoala

Stealth9mo

It really is.

CosmicPickle

Microsoft9mo

@Heart many times we make emotional decisions and later justify it using logic?

Since your logic seems pretty bogus (as others have called out) are you sure you're not stuck in this cycle?

SparklyPanda

EY9mo

Yes, you are a AITA.... you are the reason independent girls are also called gold diggers... Really hate your kind

SparklyPanda

EY9mo

And in which world USD and INR can be compared... you did not bet on your boyfriend's future... ge doesn't deserve you tbh

SparklyPanda

EY9mo

I mean you don't deserve him

PerkyWalrus

Deloitte9mo

Hi @Heart

I have a few questions which can help you get clarity.

Do you think he is incapable of taking a stand for you in front of taunts from in laws?
Do you doubt his parenting? If not, why are you doubting his parents. (Just because it happened with someone else??)
What type of pleasure/status does him having master degree gives you/your family?Is it something which can't be achieved with time?
Do you think there is a time in the future where he will earn significantly more than you? If yes, then why are you thinking short term.
Do you guarantee yourself that "perfect match" would have better compatibility with you emotionally and would respect you in all up and downs is a better human at the core? Can you surely answer this after knowing a person for 4 years vs 4 months.

DancingKoala

Stealth9mo

Honestly, I know he would stand up for me. Throughout our 4 years together, he's always been protective and supportive. I've seen him handle difficult situations with maturity, including standing up to his own family on other issues. I might be unfairly projecting my fears onto him.
You make a valid point about generalizing from my cousin's experience. I've never actually met his parents properly (only video calls), yet I'm assuming they'll be like my cousin's in-laws. He comes from a educated family and has always shown progressive values. Maybe I'm letting one negative example cloud my judgment.
The Masters degree... you're right. It's more about status for my family than actual capability. He's brilliant at what he does, and nothing stops him from pursuing higher education later if he wants to. I realize now I'm prioritizing a piece of paper over years of proven competence and character.
This really struck me. He's incredibly talented and hardworking. The salary difference is mainly because of geographic location, not capability. If he moves to the US or even continues growing his career in India, there's every possibility he could out-earn me. I am thinking very short-term.
This is the hardest truth to face. How can a few video calls and "perfect on paper" credentials compare to 4 years of actually experiencing someone's character? I've seen him handle stress, celebrate my successes without ego, support me through tough times, and grow together. I know his core values, his flaws, and his strengths. With the arranged match, I'm basically gambling on surface-level compatibility.

DizzyMochi

Siemens9mo

Mann, these questions and the replies✨

GroovyPanda

Infosys9mo

Don't text that leave it it kills a men more than you think

DancingKoala

Stealth9mo

But I am not a robot. I have strong feelings as well

GroovyPanda

Infosys9mo

💙

ZestyPanda

TCS9mo

It takes time to understand that he’s loved a wrong person. But I’m sure he’ll understand now or then. It’s good for him actually. What if this happens after marriage and later divorce?

DancingKoala

Stealth9mo

Could be. But it doesn’t mean that my feelings aren’t real.

Discover more

Curated from across

Confessions7mo

by JumpyPandaSoftware Lead

Engaged 💍💔 but...

I am keeping it short.

I got engaged last year. Everything was going good until I came to know that see had a boyfriend and they even kissed.

I am continuously overthinking since then. FYI, I don't had any relationship in past and I...

Top comments

Break it off. What does she mean her ex loves her more than you do? Then why is she marrying you? THIS IS A SUPER BIG...

She likes you and she still loves her ex. Hmm. What can go wrong?! What you need is mentorship. Reach out to her e...

Confessions13mo

by JazzyMarshmallowInfosys

Depression

hi all, Please just pour some ideas ,I am in relationship with my boyfriend for 2 years,My parents are accepting my love .THe problem here in his mom don't get to our marriage untill his elder brother gets married but my parents are urgi...

Indian Startups6mo

by GigglyLlamaFounder

Sharing my story of being betrayed in my startup

Six years ago, in a cramped PG in Bellandur, there was a ton of rain that had waterlogged everything. I thought about starting a men's grooming company at that time, because a lot of my friends were complaining about hairfall problem due...